Share

Technical comparison

There are three technical criteria a modern website must fulfill:


  • The site must validate: this means its code follows a specific standard. These are technical specifications by the W3 Consortium, and they are there to make sure your website works the same way on all devices and Web Browsers.
  • The site must conform to WCAG 2 - a standard for accessibility that makes sure anybody will be able to use your site (for example with a Braille Reader). Simply put, it defines how information may be structured and presented. In Canada, the European Union, and the EEC, public websites must conform to WCAG 2 by law (we tested to Level AA, which is already law in the EU and EEC: in Ontario, Level A is required today, with Level AA required from 2021).
  • Section 508: In the United States, public sites must conform to the Section 508 Act, by law. Section 508 is a similar standard to WCAG 2.


We compared FirstMagic with 15 other publishing platforms. Here´s the result:


PlatformUse their own product?Websites testedValidatesWCAG 2Section 508
Below: Empty, new, completely vanilla sites we created with vendor cloud services
Google Sites
Not applicableVanilla example site
NoNoNo
FirstMagic
YesVanilla example site
YesYesYes
Sitefinity
YesVanilla example site
NoNoNo
Weebly
YesVanilla example site
NoNoNo
Wix
YesVanilla example site
NoNoNo
WordPress
YesVanilla example site
NoNoNo
Below: platforms that did not have online service: here, we tested both their own Homepages and live sites built on the platform. We picked recommended sites from their own portfolios for testing where possible.
Drupal
YesVanilla Test site
YesYesYes
Blackboard
NoTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoYes
CivicPlus
NoTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
EpiServer
YesTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
Kentico
YesTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
Moodle
YesOfficial demo testing site
NoNoNo
Sharepoint
Not applicableTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
SiteCore
YesTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
Umbraco
YesTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo
Virtual Towns & Schools
YesTest site 1 | Test site 2
NoNoNo


Of all the platforms tested, only Drupal and FirstMagic fullfills all criteria.


Testing tools used:

https://validator.w3.org for validation, and

https://achecker.ca/checker/index.php for both WCAG and S508